£3,090 to set up broadband, £3,000 for a speech coach and £546 to clean the drains: the worst Scottish MP expenses
We went through all 21,017 expense lines filed by Scotland's MPs since 2022. Here are the claims that made us stop and read them twice. Every one was approved. Every one was paid by you.

On this page
£3,090 to set up broadband. £3,000 for a speech coach. £546 to clean the drains at a . £13,117 to post a glossy report about the MP through every letterbox. All paid for by you, and all sitting in a spreadsheet almost nobody reads.
We went through every one of the 21,017 expense lines filed by Scotland's current MPs since 2022. Line by line. These are the ones that made us stop and read them twice.
And here's the thing. , the body that runs MPs' expenses, approved every single one. Nobody broke the rules. The rules just let them do this.
£3,090
Claimed by Chris Law MP in July 2022 for one thing: setting up broadband at his home.
The typical phone or internet setup claim by a Scottish MP is £90. The next biggest is £691.
1. £3,090 just to set up broadband at home
On 25 July 2022, Chris Law, then the SNP MP for Dundee West, claimed £3,090 from the public purse. 's record describes it in five words: "Home 5G mobile broadband installation". It was paid in full.
5G home broadband is just a box you plug into the wall. No engineer. No installation. In July 2022, Three were giving the box away free with a monthly plan. Plenty of people just use their phone as a hotspot.
What this normally costs
Setting up home broadband in July 2022, compared with Chris Law's claim
| What | Cost |
|---|---|
| Three's 5G home broadband router, July 2022 | Free with a monthly plan |
| Starlink satellite broadband kit, made for the remotest homes, July 2022 | £529 |
| A typical phone or internet setup claim by a Scottish MP | £90 |
| The next biggest setup claim by any Scottish MP | £691 |
| Chris Law's claim | £3,090 |
So why not just get normal broadband like everyone else? Almost every home in the country can. Ofcom says 99% of homes in Dundee could get fast broadband that year. The record doesn't even say which home this was for: his own, or the flat in London taxpayers were already renting for him.
Even Starlink, the satellite kit for the remotest homes in the country, cost £529 at the time. His claim was nearly six times that. And we're not told who was paid.
Questions Chris Law should answer
Which home was it for? Who was paid? And what did £3,090 actually buy?
2. A speech coach, and the drains cleaned at his second home
Angus MacDonald, the Lib Dem MP for Inverness, Skye and West Ross-shire, billed £3,000 in July 2025 for a "personalised presentation and speech skills workshop". Talking is the job. And that money came out of his staffing budget, the money that's meant for the people who help his constituents.
In March 2026 he billed £546 for "professional pressure jet wash" and "mechanical cable" cleaning of the drains at his . The same year he billed £3,314 for that home's energy bills. It's a home where he claims no rent.
3. Paying to put their own name through your door
- John Grady (Labour) paid £13,116.80 for the "printing and delivery of MP Annual Report to constituents". Frank McNally paid £9,974 and Andrew Bowie £5,898 for theirs. allows these as long as there's no party politics in them. They still put the MP's name and face through every door.
- Euan Stainbank (Labour) paid £3,300 for an "Advertising board to advertise Euan as local MP and contact details. To be advertised for 1 year." A billboard of himself, paid for by the people he represents.
4. Consultants and PR firms, on top of their own staff
Every MP gets a big budget for staff. Some still paid outside firms on top.
- Melanie Ward (Labour) paid £10,000 for a "Policy and Office set up consultant". She also claimed £7,000 for "research and writing of local industrial strategy", then paid all £7,000 back.
- Gregor Poynton (Labour) paid £9,600 to BB Partners Advisory Ltd, a firm in Crawley, for "Comms and Media Support".
- Joani Reid (Labour) paid Causeway Creative, a and web firm, £24,664, more than any other MP in the UK. She told The Scotsman she had "not used any public money to hire any consultant or consultancy services for public or media relations". 's records show £18,664 of it filed as "Comms & Media". Put side by side, they don't match.
5. Dinners, a Christmas lunch, sofas and phones
- Graeme Downie (Labour): £962.65 for a "business dinner on behalf of Graeme Downie".
- Christine Jardine (Lib Dem): £510 on one day for a staff Christmas lunch and a team building event.
- Pamela Nash (Labour): £3,182 at DFS and IKEA for her office.
- John Lamont (Conservative): £1,248 for an "Iphone and protection case".
- Dave Doogan (SNP): £892.80 for a "Newspaper Column Invoice". The record doesn't say what that was for.
6. Second homes, paid for by you
MPs work in two places, so the public pays for a . They can even own it and still claim the bills. Douglas Alexander claimed £4,093 for council tax on his house in East Lothian, which he lists as his . East Lothian charges double council tax on . raised MPs' budgets to cover charges like that, so you pick up the extra too.
Dr Zubir Ahmed billed £37,359 for 295 nights in London hotels in a single year, about £127 a night, mostly month-long block bookings of a flat (every claim, night by night). John Grady billed £42,000 in London rent. That's £3,500 a month.
7. The names that keep coming up
Go through enough of these and the same names keep popping up.
Repeat names
Scottish MPs who appear again and again in the strangest claims
| MP | What they claimed |
|---|---|
| Graeme Downie (Labour) | The highest non staff expenses in Scotland (£151,954), a £41,435 London flat, a £963 business dinner and a £2,936 letter folding machine |
| Chris Law (SNP) | A £3,090 broadband setup, £6,292 on car parking in one year, a £28,200 London flat, and the most of any Scottish MP on hotels in Europe (£2,822) |
| Angus MacDonald (Lib Dem) | A £3,000 speech workshop, £546 to clean drains and £3,314 of energy bills on a second home where he claims no rent |
8. Why you've never heard about any of this
does publish every claim. But it publishes them as a spreadsheet of 59,503 lines a year. Thousands of lines are lumped into one yearly total, and some hide who was paid. It's not secret. It's just that almost nobody has the time to read it.
So we did. You can see all of it in plain English on the receipts page, and every Scottish MP side by side on all 57 MPs ranked.
All within the rules
approved and paid every claim on this page. We found no broken rules. The question is whether the rules should allow any of it.
Ask your own MP to explain their receipts
Put in your postcode, see what your MP claimed, and send them a ready written email asking them to explain.
Put it to your MP